The best coffee roasters in New York

The 20 top specialty coffee roasters in New York, ranked using independent quality data — expert cupping scores, industry awards, and community reviews. No paid placements, no affiliate fluff.

Last updated May 6, 2026 · Data refreshed weekly.

1. 1

   McNulty's Tea & Coffee Co.

   29 coffees tracked·avg US$3.47/100g·Top expert score: 92

   Top picks

   • Decaffeinated Mocha JavaIndonesia · US$2.14/100g
   • Organic Coffee: Organic SumatraIndonesia · US$4.85/100g
   • Old Judge's Secret BlendBlend · US$4.01/100g
2. 2

   Nguyen Coffee Supply

   11 coffees tracked·avg US$15.36/100g

   Top picks

   • Dark Roast Coffee TrioBlend · US$18.53/100g
   • Dalat (100% Arabica)Blend · US$19.47/100g
   • 5 lb Bag: Truegrit (100% Robusta)Blend · US$5.69/100g
3. 3

   Utica Coffee Roasting Co.

   31 coffees tracked·avg US$4.59/100g

   Top picks

   • Tanzania LukululuTanzania · US$5.29/100g
   • Firehouse BlendBlend
   • Decaf French ToastUnknown · US$4.40/100g
4. 4

   Gillies Coffee Co.

   25 coffees tracked·avg US$2.56/100g

   Top picks

   • MacadamiaBlend · US$2.91/100g
   • Green Coffee - Costa Rica TarrazuCosta Rica · US$2.31/100g
   • Vanilla HazelnutBlend · US$2.91/100g
5. 5

   Genuine Origin

   24 coffees tracked·avg US$2.40/100g

   Top picks

   • Brazil Salmo Plus Natural 2/3 Scr 16+ SSFC 2026Brazil · US$2.02/100g
   • Ethiopia Guji Danbi Udo G2 Natural 2025Ethiopia · US$2.27/100g
   • Colombia Huila Pitalito El Tiple Supremo 2026Colombia · US$2.10/100g
6. 6

   Sweetleaf Coffee Roasters

   24 coffees tracked·avg US$5.52/100g

   Top picks

   • ROASTER’S CHOICE 2.5lbBlend · US$6.61/100g
   • MEXICO SAN FERNANDOMexico · US$7.31/100g
   • MEXICO SAN FERNANDO 5lbMexico · US$5.51/100g
7. 7

   Whole Latte Love

   23 coffees tracked·avg US$2.73/100g

   Top picks

   • Maromas Platinea Whole Bean Espresso 2.2lbsBlend · US$2.70/100g
   • Maromas Orphea Whole Bean EspressoBlend · US$2.70/100g
   • Lavazza Qualita Rossa Whole Bean Medium Roast Espresso CoffeeBlend · US$2.20/100g
8. 8

   Cerini Coffee & Gifts

   19 coffees tracked·avg US$2.92/100g

   Top picks

   • 75% ESPRESSO DECAF + 25% COLOMBIAN DECAF - GROUND FOR TURKISH (1 LB)Blend · US$3.35/100g
   • 100% Colombian - Coffee BeansColombia · US$1.44/100g
   • Bronx Zoo Blend - Cerini Original Blend - 1 lb BagsBlend · US$3.00/100g
9. 9

   Chris Coffee Service

   16 coffees tracked·avg US$3.44/100g

   Top picks

   • Sumatra Full City RoastIndonesia · US$3.68/100g
   • Dolce TazzaBlend · US$3.58/100g
   • CFT Organic EthiopianEthiopia · US$4.12/100g
10. 10

    Filicori Zecchini USA

    15 coffees tracked·avg US$15.15/100g

    Top picks

    • Forte | Ground CoffeeBlend · US$4.38/100g
    • Grand Cru Brazil | Whole Bean CoffeeBrazil · US$5.15/100g
    • 100 Percento Arabica | Whole Bean CoffeeBlend · US$5.56/100g
11. 11

    Sahadi's

    13 coffees tracked

    Top picks

    • Brooklyn BlendBlend
    • French RoastUnknown
    • Breakfast BlendBlend
12. 12

    Trade Coffee

    13 coffees tracked·avg US$6.82/100g

    Top picks

    • Colombia PalmeraColombia · US$7.09/100g
    • Milk & HoneyBlend · US$5.48/100g
    • Tanzania Gaia Estate PeaberryTanzania · US$7.09/100g
13. 13

    Kahawa 1893 Coffee

    12 coffees tracked·avg US$6.44/100g

    Top picks

    • Decaf Metaboost Blend - Fuel for Optimized MetabolismBlend
    • Safari Blend - Medium Roast CoffeeBlend · US$5.59/100g
    • Serengeti Blend - Dark Roast CoffeeBlend · US$5.59/100g
14. 14

    Verve Coffee Roasters

    12 coffees tracked·avg US$7.97/100g

    Top picks

    • Ethiopia Anasora Natural EspressoEthiopia · US$8.09/100g
    • Mexico La PerlaMexico · US$6.76/100g
    • Ethiopia Tamiru Tadesse Hybrid Washed Farmlevel ReserveEthiopia · US$12.71/100g
15. 15

    BKG

    12 coffees tracked·avg US$4.89/100g

    Top picks

    • Sumatra Takengon MeukatIndonesia · US$5.64/100g
    • Colombia Planadas Tolima - 5lbs BagColombia · US$4.15/100g
    • Colombia Planadas TolimaColombia · US$5.64/100g
16. 16

    Rural Coffee

    11 coffees tracked·avg US$6.12/100g

    Top picks

    • Dominican Republic EstateDominican Republic · US$5.29/100g
    • Ethiopia HarrarEthiopia · US$5.29/100g
    • Sumatra MandhedlingIndonesia · US$5.88/100g
17. 17

    Ateaz Organic Coffee & Tea

    11 coffees tracked·avg US$6.01/100g

    Top picks

    • ORGANIC COLOMBIAN SIERRA NEVADAColombia · US$5.88/100g
    • ORGANIC ETHIOPIAN YERGACHEFFEEthiopia · US$7.35/100g
    • ORGANIC HONDURAN MARCALAHonduras · US$5.88/100g
18. 18

    Klatch

    11 coffees tracked·avg US$6.80/100g

    Top picks

    • Dark ThunderBlend · US$7.09/100g
    • EurekaBlend · US$5.48/100g
    • Guatemala Huehuetenango Rio AzulGuatemala · US$7.09/100g
19. 19

    Crown Street Roasting Company

    10 coffees tracked·avg US$7.85/100g

    Top picks

    • EthiopiaEthiopia · US$8.53/100g
    • Colombia - Santa Barbara EstateColombia · US$8.24/100g
    • HondurasHonduras · US$8.24/100g
20. 20

    Intelligentsia Coffee

    10 coffees tracked·avg US$9.81/100g

    Top picks

    • Kenya Kangocho ABKenya · US$8.13/100g
    • Wing Logo Bib ApronBlend · US$17.06/100g
    • Peru Agua Cristalina SOEPeru · US$9.71/100g